WHOOP 2025 Review

Whoop homepage

The Most Inaccurate… Yet Surprisingly Valuable Fitness Tracker I Own**

Fitness trackers in 2025 are like relationships: none of them are perfect, all of them have flaws, and the ones you stick with are the ones that give you something meaningful in return.

My journey with WHOOP has been exactly that — messy, surprising, frustrating, and somehow still worth it. Two years in, I’ve owned the Whoop 4.0, the MG, and now the latest generation. And after countless workouts, zone sessions, sleep studies, hikes through Colorado, and DexaFit scans…

Here’s the real story.

The WHOOP 4.0: The Rocky Start

Let me start with the older generation I first strapped on.

The Whoop 4.0 never truly fit me right.

The strap felt uncomfortable.

The battery life was “meh.”

And the on-wrist charger? Bulky, warm, and annoying under long sleeves — like wearing a matchbox under your jacket.

But the real problem was the heart-rate sensor.

The readings jumped around like they were plotting against me. WHOOP claimed I was in Zones 3–5 on light walks. Meanwhile, Apple Watch and Garmin were chilling comfortably in Zone 1 or 2.

Take it off for ten minutes, and you’d get a reminder text like WHOOP was a needy partner asking where you went. The alternative placements (bicep sleeve, arm strap, etc.) didn’t help much either. They were uncomfortable for long wear, so the 4.0 eventually retired into my drawer.

The WHOOP App: The True Superstar

Now let me give WHOOP some well-earned credit.

The app is phenomenal.

In terms of pure health insights, I put Garmin at the top — but WHOOP’s app isn’t far behind. Clean. Deep. Intuitive. Rich with actionable data. The kind of information that pulls you in and makes you rethink your sleep, recovery, and daily habits.

There were moments I almost let go of my Oura Ring because the WHOOP app made wellness feel so precise… almost scientific.

Almost.

But the hardware? That’s what held me back.

The WHOOP MG: The Upgrade That Didn’t Feel Like an Upgrade

Then came the WHOOP MG announcement.

Remember when early customers were promised free upgrades?

Yeah… that disappeared like a Snapchat message.

I upgraded anyway — and instantly felt the sting. The features didn’t justify losing two months of membership time.

Red Flag #1: Blood Pressure

To use the BP feature, you need a separate blood pressure device to set it up.

If I already have a medical-grade BP cuff… why am I paying WHOOP for this feature?

Red Flag #2: ECG Paywall

The ECG feature lives behind a subscription wall, while my Apple Watch is literally doing it for free from my wrist.

After a month, I downgraded. No shade — just honesty.

Back With WHOOP Again — Smaller, Lighter, Better… But Still Not Perfect

Fast-forward to now. The new WHOOP is:

✔ Smaller

✔ Lighter

✔ More comfortable

✔ Better battery life

✔ Far more accurate step tracking

But all the bands I bought for the Whoop 4.0?

Useless after the upgrade. Another L on the bank account.

Still, the new design is genuinely good. It feels like WHOOP finally made a band you can forget you’re wearing.

But then… the heart-rate sensor showed up again like an unwelcome plot twist.

The Heart-Rate Accuracy Problem (aka The Dealbreaker)

After my DexaFit AI scan, I learned exactly where my zone-2 fat-burning range sits. Perfect time to test WHOOP, right?

Except WHOOP regularly jumps to 160–180 bpm during basic workouts, while Apple Watch and Garmin sit calmly in the correct zone.

In 2025, this shouldn’t be happening.

WHOOP still has one of the worst heart-rate sensors on the market.

And when the main hardware metric is inaccurate, it casts a shadow over every piece of data the app produces.

So now, I don’t rely on WHOOP for fitness metrics.

I let it piggyback off my Apple Watch.

Sleep Tracking: Where WHOOP Redeems Itself

Sleep and zone training are my main goals this year, so this category matters.

Here’s how the trackers stack up for me:

1. Apple Watch — Most Accurate, Barebones Details

It nails the accuracy, but the data is extremely basic.

2. Oura Ring — Fantastic Sleep Tracker, Weak for Workouts

A staple for recovery and nightly trends.

3. WHOOP — Deepest Data, Good Accuracy

WHOOP gives you:

• Sleep performance

• Sleep consistency

• Hours vs. needed

• 30-day averages

• Sleep sufficiency

• Efficiency

• And layers of recovery metrics

It’s rich. It’s helpful. And it’s honestly one of WHOOP’s strongest selling points.

4. Garmin — Amazing Device, Sleep Still Feels Off

Great for outdoor athletes. Not amazing for sleep.

The Screenless Life: A Blessing and a Burden

WHOOP goes screenless to keep you focused… but sometimes it does the opposite.

If I’m rushing in the morning, I don’t always want to dive into an app and scroll through pages of data. Apple Watch gives me my score at a glance.

Starting workouts on WHOOP also means grabbing my phone. And auto-detection? If you do anything physical — yard work, cleaning, carrying groceries — WHOOP thinks you completed 18 workouts in an hour.

So I turned auto-workouts off.

Bottom Line: Should You Buy WHOOP in 2025?

YES — IF you want:

• Deep sleep and recovery insights

• Beautiful data visualizations

• A lightweight, comfortable band

• A subscription that’s cheaper than Garmin’s upgrade cycle

• A tracker that makes you think about your daily habits

NO — IF you need:

• Accurate heart-rate data

• Real-time tracking

• A screen

• Workout reliability

• Strong on-device metrics

My Final Take

WHOOP is flawed.

But it’s also one of my favorite wellness companions of 2025.

The app alone is worth the membership for people who love health data, deep sleep analysis, and recovery coaching.

Just don’t expect accuracy from the heart-rate sensor.